The Union Jack fluttering above the beach in Lyme Regis on the South Coast.
On Thursday 18th September in the year of 2014
the Scottish people are voting for independence.
They are voting to separate themselves from the rest of the United
Kingdom and go it alone as a separate political and economic entity. They could
of course vote to stay as part of the United Kingdom too. However, at this
moment, two days before this momentous vote, the decision of the Scottish people
hangs in the balance.
The people on these islands began to appear about 500.000
years ago and then the Ice Age came and they disappeared. About 12000 BC the
climate warmed up and the ice melted. People returned. They could walk here
because the land that later formed the British Isles was joined to Europe by a
land mass. This land bridge, called Doggerland later disappeared under rising sea levels Evidence for hunter gathering has been found in the remains of bones
and in cave drawings. To hunt, especially the larger animals like mammoths,
bison,elk and aurochs, people needed to group together. At this stage only small
groups would be required to hunt and trap large animals. It is easy to see how
small communities probably family sized communities needed to work together and it is easy to
understand that they would form traditions within families and also pass down
family stories. The seasons and the weather patterns also ruled
their lives.This early instinct to form small communities and work together
developed through the centuries and millennia.
We can look back at the vast expanse of the history of these
islands starting from hunter gatherers and the requirements of their lifestyle to the appearance from Europe of people
who had started to farm and so formed
static permanent communities and built houses and huts. The Neolithic period
or New Stone age was the time people formed themselves into tribes and became far more powerful
because of their numbers. Vast building projects like the stone circles
at Avebury and Stone Henge and giant mounds like Silbury Hill in Wiltshire ,
the hill forts such as the vast Maiden Castle in Dorset, used for protection from
neighbouring kingdoms, were built. They required great technological
ingenuity and the development of tools. The coming together of tribes into
kingdoms required leaders, holy men , traditions, rituals and beliefs. They
created strong powerful and increasingly wealthy communities. Later, metals
began to be smelted naming the Bronze Age and Iron Age. Celtic tribes moved
here from Europe in about 500 BC and brought new traditions and technologies.
The Romans invaded in 43 BC, stayed a few hundred years and
built towns and roads and then left.
Invaders from Europe came,. The Angles and Saxons and they formed Kingdoms like
Mercia and Wessex. These kingdoms often fought each other. The Vikings came and
invaded and took their part of the country mostly in the north in an area
termed The Danelaw. The Saxons fought back under Alfred the Great and stemmed the tide of Viking authority. William the
Norman invaded in 1066 and took over a
country we could recognise today as
England stretching from the South coast up to Northumberland and the borders of
Scotland.
Between 1282 and 1283 Edward I invaded Wales and built
massive castles at Caernarvon in the north and Pembroke in the south and a
whole range of other castles throughout Wales to keep it subjugated and placed
it under English rule. During the 1290’s he turned his attention to Scotland. He
didn’t manage to subjugate Scotland. There were defeats as well as successes but
war was an expensive undertaking and Edward I had problems with taxation. His
son Edward II continued the Scottish campaign but was unsuccessful too.
Scotland began its joining with the United Kingdom when Elizabeth 1
died childless and the Tudor dynasty came to an end. Her cousin, James VII of Scotland,
the son of Mary Queen of Scots, was invited to become King of England. He accepted
and became James I of England.The crowns were united but the countries stayed separate until full union was achieved through the act of union in 1707. The forces of trade and influence within Empire brought us together. There was a need to be together for the greater good.
The Tudors had tried to subjugate and rule Ireland but had not proceeded much beyond Dublin and The Pale.After the English Civil war Cromwell sent armies to Ireland to subjugate them. The Irish had been royalist in sympathy and would have caused a problem if they were not controlled. It was a severe and brutal campaign and Cromwell is hated in Ireland to this day. Ireland's joining the union was a parallel coming together with Scotalnd. It achieved its act of union in 1800. Differing forces of religion and trade played their part. Also in both cases Scotland and Ireland were seen as routes to invasion from England's enemies. It was better for all, economically and militarily to be together.
The Tudors had tried to subjugate and rule Ireland but had not proceeded much beyond Dublin and The Pale.After the English Civil war Cromwell sent armies to Ireland to subjugate them. The Irish had been royalist in sympathy and would have caused a problem if they were not controlled. It was a severe and brutal campaign and Cromwell is hated in Ireland to this day. Ireland's joining the union was a parallel coming together with Scotalnd. It achieved its act of union in 1800. Differing forces of religion and trade played their part. Also in both cases Scotland and Ireland were seen as routes to invasion from England's enemies. It was better for all, economically and militarily to be together.
The history of the United Kingdom, is therefore bloody and
often cruel but it is also the history of a coming together which enabled
growth, industrial and agricultural revolutions, great art, music and literature. This creative force occurred because of the forging together of four united countries, England, Scotland, Wales and Ireland into a place
that is so unique and special and has this deep shared history. It is in the
gradual unifying of the whole that it has become an amazing and special place.
It is easy for nationalists in Scotland, or England, Wales
and Ireland to want to separate from the others because of a deep sense of remembered
hurt, pride and belief in their traditions but they are not looking at the
whole picture. They are being selfish and ready to damage the whole for their
narrow beliefs and so doing they are going to diminish the strength and power
that comes from being together rather than apart. The British Isles, The United
Kingdom, is going to be a smaller place not just in land mass if the YES vote wins on Thursday. The
strength derived from being together will be weakened. We will not be quite so
amazing.
Rather like those early hunter gatherers who needed each
other to help bring down a woolly mammoth otherwise, as individuals they would not have been able to survive, we all need each other now in our four countries to
stay strong and grow. Within a group it is still possible to have individual traits,
traditions and beliefs. Often strength and creativity is derived from the
diversities within a whole. A synergy is formed. The history of our islands has
been one of struggle, pain and war, but through the searing heat of that melding
together it has made us unique and special.
A piper in Princes Street next to Scott's monument. I hope we can call this bit of land part of The United Kingdom come Thursday!!!!
Thanks for this, Tony. An interesting post. The Scots are a great people - with a wonderful culture and history. They have made enormous contributions to Science, Engineering, Philosophy, Economics, Music and Literature. They have a beautiful land. Their yearning for national independence is understandable; it is certainly driven partly by a sense of grievance - feelings of being oppressed or denigrated.
ReplyDeleteBut the effects of going it alone would be more negative than positive, as time progressed. I think the Quebecois now realize that a separate Quebec would be a vulnerable and weakened entity. They thrive in a unified Canada - with all the benefits provided by a bilingual, bi-cultural nation.
I hope the NO vote wins; but I hope also that this whole process will encourage both peoples to acknowledge each others particular qualities and value. Patriotism often gets out of control. Too many xenophobes stirring up trouble and agitating for derision and division.
Tony, You wrote an eloquent essay in favor of Scotland staying within the UK. Your friend, Clive, pointed out an excellent example for inclusion with Canada. It did work out. As an American, I can only watch and wonder. Mary
ReplyDelete